Agency or in-house employee for social media: which should you choose?
- Social media
For a B2B company—a business that sells to other businesses—the more suitable channel is the one where it can reach relevant buyers and consistently create content that supports their decisions. Consider LinkedIn when professional context, expert discussion and connections with specific business roles matter. Consider Instagram when you can convincingly demonstrate a product, process or result visually and have a relevant audience there. With limited resources, choose one primary channel, separate organic activity from advertising and test your initial assumptions over 30 days.
The B2B label alone is not enough to choose a social media channel. An industrial equipment supplier, an architectural practice and a packaging manufacturer may have different customers, sales cycles and content creation capabilities.
Before deciding, answer four questions:
Look for answers in conversations with customers and sales, existing enquiries and profile data. A competitor’s presence can provide a starting point for research, but it does not confirm that the channel is right for you.
LinkedIn is worth considering when the buying decision requires expert explanations, an understanding of a business problem and trust in the people behind the service.
Useful organic content may include analysis of a customer problem, explanations of your approach, insights from project delivery and expert opinions. If you do not have permission to feature a client, you can explain the process without disclosing confidential information.
LinkedIn is not limited to text. Its official guidance for Pages includes images, videos and documents, so your content choices do not need to be restricted to long expert posts. LinkedIn Pages best practices
Access to experts matters. If marketing cannot obtain information from the people who understand the product and customers, consistently producing credible expert content will be difficult. Agree on who will contribute expertise and how much time they can allocate.
Consider Instagram when you can show what a buyer needs to evaluate: workmanship, materials, product details, a process or a practical application.
Hypothetical example: a hospitality equipment manufacturer could demonstrate how a machine is cleaned, how a workspace is arranged and how the equipment is used. This content can help a business buyer understand the solution before submitting an enquiry.
Visual appeal alone is not enough, however. A post should answer a buyer’s question: what problem the product solves, who it suits or what to check before ordering.
Instagram makes less sense if you lack access to materials, the ability to shoot content or someone to prepare explanations and respond to messages. In that case, assess the cost of establishing content production before adding another channel.
Use this table as an initial assessment. Test the recommendations against your own audience and results.
| Criterion | When LinkedIn may have the advantage | When Instagram may have the advantage |
|---|---|---|
| Audience | You can identify buyers through business roles and professional interests. | Relevant buyers use the platform to follow products, suppliers and examples of practical applications. |
| Buying process | You need to explain your approach, risks and business value. | Showing workmanship or use helps buyers make an initial assessment. |
| Content | You have expert insights, analysis and explanations. | You have quality photographs, demonstrations and material from your working process. |
| People’s availability | Experts can contribute to content preparation and discussion. | The team can regularly prepare visual materials and explanations. |
| Activity goal | You want to build recognition for your expertise and encourage relevant business conversations. | You want to showcase your offering and its applications, and generate interest in a specific solution. |
| Resources | You can provide expert input, editing and regular communication. | You can provide photography or filming, editing and regular communication. |
Identify the criteria that matter most to your business. If the audience is not relevant, having attractive photographs will not compensate for choosing the wrong channel.
An organic presence includes publishing and communication without paying to distribute individual posts. Paid advertising involves a separate budget and campaign settings.
Good organic performance does not prove that the same content will succeed as an ad. Similarly, a small follower count alone does not indicate how a paid campaign would perform.
LinkedIn offers ad targeting criteria such as job title, job function, industry and company size. These can help define a B2B audience, but their availability does not guarantee a sufficiently large audience or qualified enquiries. Official LinkedIn ad targeting options
For Instagram, Meta enables content promotion and campaign creation through its advertising tools. Your choice of advertising approach should connect to your goal, message and measurement. Meta’s guide to promoting content
For both channels, budget separately for the work, production and ad spend. Also check the landing page: users should understand the offering and be able to take the next step easily.
The purpose of this plan is to test whether the workflow is practical and identify early signs of interest. With a long sales cycle, 30 days is not enough to reach a final conclusion about sales impact.
Choose one audience, one business goal and one primary channel. Write down why you expect that combination to work.
Record existing results, how you will identify a relevant enquiry and the time available. Assign a responsible person and check the profile, contact details and landing page.
Choose a few topics based on real customer questions. Define the message, format and next step for each.
Prepare a sustainable schedule—for example, two posts a week as an initial working assumption. This is not a universally recommended frequency. Allow time for expert review, approval and responding to your audience.
Track questions, relevant conversations, landing page visits and enquiries, while accounting for measurement limitations. Also record the time spent preparing content.
If you are testing ads, set the budget in advance and track paid results separately. With a small budget and limited data, avoid changing the audience, message and destination simultaneously.
Assess whether responses come from relevant people, which topics start conversations and whether the team can sustain the chosen workflow.
Decide whether to continue the test, adjust the content or explore another channel. A lack of enquiries may also indicate an issue with the message, offering or landing page.
Do not choose LinkedIn simply because you sell to businesses, or dismiss Instagram simply because it feels less formal. Also avoid launching both channels without the capacity to adapt content for each.
Assess reactions alongside audience quality and the goal of the activity. For more communication ideas, see “5 key areas for increasing social media engagement”.
If customers primarily search actively for a highly specific solution, consider other channels too. Social media may then play a supporting role within your digital marketing strategy.
You can use the same expert source material or shoot. Adapt the introduction, format and call to action to the role of each channel.
They can participate if they want to and have support. Agree on topics and confidentiality boundaries, and ensure continuity through the company’s own channels as well.
Review the length of your sales cycle and earlier indicators of interest. Do not draw a final conclusion about the channel’s return on investment from a small sample.
Yes, if each has a clear role, a responsible person and sufficient resources. With limited capacity, test one primary channel first.
If you need to choose a channel and turn your company’s expertise into content, explore Social Wizard’s social media marketing services. For an initial conversation, prepare an outline of your customer, sales process and available resources so we can assess a suitable starting plan.